Sigourney
Weaver as Alice Goodwin voices a visceral scream of near despair that
many women border on in the struggle to juggle the almost impossible
demands of a fulfilling marriage, career, and motherhood. We live in
times when we are told that it takes a village to raise a family. Here,
the village is a rural Wisconsin farm community where Howard (David
Strathairn) and Alice Goodwin have moved with their two young daughters.
Howard works hard on fulfilling his dream of being a dairy farmer, and
Alice struggles with raising the girls while working as a
school nurse. The tensions are literally ripping Alice apart as she
scrambles through a messy house and tries to turn a deaf ear and a blind
eye on her elder daughter’s constant tantrums and insults.
Alice’s only friend, Theresa Collins (Julianne Moore), also with
two daughters, lives in stark contrast in outward appearance. Theresa’s
house is a model of order. Tins of freshly baked muffins rest on a
spotless countertop, and even something as messy as finger-painting
projects are left neatly on a dining room table. Theresa’s husband has
a flourishing career so that Theresa can afford to be a stay-at-home
Mom, a luxury Alice can only dream of. Despite their differences, these
women are close friends who share the intimacies of womanly
conversation, family barbecues, and mutual support as each takes the
other’s girls for sleepovers and baby-sitting relief.
Alice is constantly pushed to the edge. At school, she shouts at a
young mother who often sends her son to school sick. At home, her older
daughter Emma is often out of control with willful disobedience and
nasty outbursts. Moreover, Howard is of little help in his laconic focus on
his world of animals, chores, and the outdoors. He is not a bad man, but
he is so absorbed in his routines and needs that he glides by Alice
oblivious to what she is experiencing. He never sees her or his
daughters as the women, as the people they really are, full of
complexity and need of his engagement in their lives.
And so this kettle of simmering discontent is set to boil when two
events shake these people irretrievably. First, Theresa’s youngest
daughter drowns in the pond at the Goodwin farm while Alice momentarily
turns her attention to childhood daydreams. While trying to peel away
from the consuming depression caused by profound grief and guilt, the
second blow strikes; Alice is arrested for sexually abusing the children
at her school.
And then, a transformation begins. Being cast into jail while
awaiting trial is a much-needed relief from all the responsibilities
pulling Alice in opposite directions. This is her only chance to face
the realities that have led her to her current situation. She is
crippled by her own expectations, and even more so by her failure to
live up to them. Although, none of what happens is her fault, she must
find a new balance, and a new connection to herself and her loved ones.
Oprah’s television show, which is featured in the jail scenes,
resonates a powerful individual need to express a scream of discontent
that may not be anyone’s fault. Yes, we as a society, as communities,
as individuals are far from nurturing the best in each of us. And yet,
this film and an underlying theme of Oprah allow the many dimensions of
our discontent to vent. Ultimately, it is up to Alice, up to all of us,
to find the balance between our personal, sometimes selfish, needs and
our responsibilities to those we love. We are all, as this film and
Oprah illustrate, maddeningly, tragically, and comically imperfect, yet
we seem to manage, even achieve greatness, when we are allowed to vent
our discontents and move forward.
A Map of the World covers the vast web of human experience in one
breath. This is not just a story about one woman’s frustrations, but a
story of genuine friendship and loyalty, joys and griefs of motherhood,
lack of spousal connection, guilt and depression, human propensity to
judge and accuse others in order to mask one’s individual
shortcomings.
In an almost painful naturalism, Sigourney Weaver, Julianne Moore,
and David Strathairn weave this rich tapestry of life. Their impeccable
timing and sense for emotional nuances is mesmerizing. The women appear
to be without make-up, full of the flaws that make them seem so
poignantly realistic. A Map of the World is a film with an every
day beginning and an every day ending, and a triumph in between.