Half
way through the prologue, which rolls in the legendary Star Wars
format, What Planet Are You From? had us bursting with laughter.
The movie continues to delight with the often wry and always funny
insights into the age-old struggle of men and women to make sense of
each other’s approach to sexual intimacy. Yes, this movie is about sex
and the ridiculous and hilarious tug of war we humans play out of our
need for pleasure, procreation, and long-term relationships. What a
brilliant idea to strip the subject of sex of its apparent taboo by
making the protagonist an alien from a planet where no one has sexual
organs, or the capacity to feel or understand emotional nuances. What
Planet Are You From? is an honest, utterly entertaining, and
insightful effort to create comedy out of human contradiction and
complexity.
The central problem of the story is presented immediately as the
opening scene reveals a huge auditorium full of alien men listening
attentively to their leader’s plan to conquer Earth by impregnating
Earth’s women. Because women do not easily allow access to their
reproductive organs, the aliens must undergo difficult training about
ways of getting women to mate. Unfortunately, the training provides no
information about the complexity of female psychology.
Garry Shandling plays Harold, the only candidate who successfully
passes the training. Armed with a series of memorized, formulaic
compliments and a newly attached human male sexual organ, he must go to
Earth, have sex with a woman, get her pregnant, and leave. Harold
expects to accomplish this in two days.
The straightforwardness of Harold’s approach is unbelievably funny.
He is never quite ready for the variety of rejection responses he gets
each time he rattles out one of his clichéd come-ons. Through the
naiveté of this goal-oriented alien, we are able to laugh at the lines
men use on women and the extent to which they actually work. We get a
chance to laugh at the discomfort that comes with the male spirit of
sexual domination, and the grief men and women give each other when the
men’s need for sex begins to clash with the women’s need for
intimacy and relationship. Because the hero is an outsider in the
contemporary gender struggle, What Planet Are You From? peers
beneath the pretentiousness and anxiety normally surrounding sex and
turns them into an equal measure of good fun and refreshing insight.
When Harold realizes that accomplishing his mission is more
complicated than he had anticipated, he settles for Susan (Annette
Bening), the only woman who seems interested in him. (Incidentally, they
met at an AA meeting Harold attends because a sleaze at work played by
Greg Kinnear convinces him that this is a great place to meet
vulnerable, easy women.) Unfortunately, Susan doesn’t want to have sex
unless she is married. Harold’s primary objective is too important to
be risked, so he plunges into marriage and quickly learns that the
confusion of dealing with a woman only gets worse when the knot is tied.
Garry Shandling is superb in balancing the puzzlement and naiveté of
an alien trying to get laid with the sweetness of a man learning to love
with the open heart of a child. The initial directness of his approach
transforms into delicious anxiety and confusion as he learns that woman
(and men) rarely say what they mean and do what they say. In a touching
and inspiring transformation, Howard begins to glean the exhilaration
and the freedom of loving and sharing his emotions.
The clever writing in What Planet Are You From? is honest to
the awkwardness of human pursuit of pleasure and the ultimate
befuddlement of sex, which is often equally adept at dividing and
uniting us. Amazingly, the movie covers an entire scope of male-female
relationship, from courtship, through marriage, sex, pregnancy, and
childbirth to the re-established balance of affection, communication,
and passion in a long-term partnership.
What Planet Are You From? made us laugh hysterically while
tickling our hearts with a touching romance. What a delightful reminder
of the magic that emerges in relationships when two people have the
strength and resolve to understand and, ultimately, incorporate sex as a
part of learning to know and share their hearts.