Sometimes,
we are moved most by a simple story well told. Such is offered by Where
the Heart Is. Natalie Portman as Novalee Nation comes of age with
luminous maturity. In a world of confusion and cynicism where young
women are so often brought down by pregnancies spawned in unstable
relationships, Novalee achieves her success by stint of will and
determination tempered with an innocence that seeks the best for people
around her. Everyone she knows, even those who have betrayed her, are
touched and empowered. Novalee, however, is not a conventional traveling
angel archetype. In her own being, she is full of doubt about her worth.
Novalee leaves Tennessee in a barely
running old heap with her handsome, white trash boyfriend (Willy Jack
played by Dylan Bruno) on a trek to the promised land of California.
They are, however, not going to Hollywood or the beach, but are headed
for Bakersfield, a central California farm town. The prospects of living
with Novalee and taking responsibility for the child prominently visible
in her very pregnant belly are just too much for Willy Jack. He abandons
Novalle at a Wal-Mart in Oklahoma. In order to survive, she camps out in
the store every night. James Frain plays Novalee’s friend Forney. He
is the reclusive librarian who is saddled with a bedridden, alcoholic,
mentally disturbed sister. Though inward most of the time, he smashes
through the plate glass window of the Wal-Mart in order to get Novalee
to the hospital to deliver her baby, Americus. The critical element of
the story is for Novalee and Forney to find a deeper love for each
other, one borne of friendship that is the bedrock of much more if they
can just communicate and overcome their lack of self-confidence.
There are no unexpected twists in the
story, just wonderful moments that unfold in dramatically powerful
scenes with great supporting actors. Stockard Channing plays an offbeat
older lady, Sister Husband, who is a warm-hearted combination of rural
Christianity, earthy fornication, and motherly love. A short sequence
features Sally Field as Novalee’s mother. Keith David plays an
avuncular store portrait photographer who starts Novalee on her way to
becoming an accomplished artist. Joan Cusack plays Ruth, a cynical but
keen eyed talent agent.
Except for the tornado sequence that
looks too much like a copy of Twister and the episodic nature of
the film, veteran TV director Matt Williams creates a balanced
adaptation of Billie Letts’s best selling novel that was an Oprah book
club selection. Some will probably complain that Where the Heart Is gushes
as a fairytale because, in "reality", young, unwed mothers
with no family connections have scant chance of making such a success of
their lives. Well, that is the strength of this film. What are
fairytales but stories with a moral to give us hope that we can
transcend difficulties, even those that seem insurmountable?
Unlike in a conventional fairytale where
magic does the trick, Novalee completes her journey to womanhood by
overcoming her own sense of insecurity and inability. Her magic comes
from fully participating in the lives of others. Novalee is touched by
and touches people who are suffering their own slings and arrows. Those
whom she loves die, betray her, steal from her, are beaten by lovers,
witness the abuse of their children, and yet they all persevere.
The most important theme weaving through
the movie is that empowered women, even those of simple or tragic
backgrounds, find and ultimately demand the men in their lives to be
worthy. This is not a feminist diatribe, however. The women in this
movie, as in real life, often attract or choose superficial hunky types
for their tight jeans and a swagger, rather than a plainer man with
deeper qualities of good heartedness, kindness, genuine respect, and
love. The junction at which a woman recognizes that seeking out unworthy
men only represents how poorly she thinks of herself is well portrayed
in Novalee’s relationship with Lexie (Ashley Judd).
Lexie is gorgeous, but she has spent
much of her youth getting pregnant by men who abandon her. Novalee finds
Lexie nearly beaten to death with her kids surrounding her. After a
hospital stay, Lexie unburdens her troubled soul to Novalee in sobs of
grief and approbation. Seeing a beautiful, intelligent woman, who seems
capable of achieving just about anything, finally admit to and let go of
the self-destructive pattern of relationships is awe-inspiring. The two
women hold each other with dramatic power that made us weep with them,
both for sadness and joy.
This is the magic in Where the Heart
Is. It doesn’t come from a wand of a fairy godmother. It comes
from the heart of a white, trailer trash, unwed teen mother who, even as
she gains the wisdom to keep at abeyance those who have betrayed her or
will hurt her, ultimately transforms her life and that of others by the
purity of love and innocence that conquers cynicism.